What separates them
A liquid filled transformer sits in a sealed tank of oil or ester fluid that both insulates and carries heat away. A dry type is cooled by air and insulated with solid materials. That single difference drives everything else, cost, size, efficiency, life and where you are allowed to put it.
Where each one wins
Liquid filled is more efficient, runs cooler, lasts longer, handles overload better and costs less per kVA. Dry type has no liquid to leak, contain or test, which is why it goes indoors, in basements, on upper floors and anywhere a spill would be a problem. Outdoors at ground level on a pad, liquid filled wins on almost every measure. Indoors, the fire and containment rules usually decide for you before efficiency is even discussed.
Life expectancy
A liquid filled distribution transformer that is not abused commonly runs 30 years or more, and utilities routinely have units well past that in service. Dry type typically runs 20 to 25 years, because its solid insulation ages faster at temperature and it has less thermal mass to ride through overloads. The gap narrows if the dry type is lightly loaded and well ventilated.
The disadvantages people do not hear about
Dry type is noisier, larger for the same rating, less tolerant of overload, and needs real ventilation, which means the room has to be designed around it. It is also more sensitive to dust, moisture and contamination, so a dirty environment shortens it considerably. Liquid filled brings its own obligations, oil sampling, containment and a spill plan.
Common questions
What is the difference between a dry type and an oil type transformer
A liquid filled transformer uses oil or ester fluid inside a sealed tank to insulate and cool. A dry type uses air and solid insulation. Liquid filled is more efficient, cheaper per kVA and longer lived. Dry type has no liquid to leak, which is why it is used indoors.
Are dry type transformers better
Not generally, only situationally. Indoors or anywhere a leak would be a serious problem, dry type is usually the right answer. Outdoors on a pad, liquid filled is more efficient, cheaper and longer lasting.
What are the disadvantages of dry type transformers
Lower efficiency, higher cost per kVA, shorter life, more audible noise, larger footprint for the same rating, poorer overload tolerance and a real ventilation requirement. They are also more affected by dust and moisture.
What is the average life expectancy of a dry type transformer
Usually 20 to 25 years in normal service, against 30 years or more for a liquid filled unit. Load, ambient temperature and how clean the environment is all move that figure substantially.
Free to cite with a link to this page. Work out current at any rating with the kVA to amps calculator.